February 2025

» "The shift toward humanized drug discovery represents one of the most significant advancements in pharmaceutical research in decades." «

Breaking Free from Animal Testing: The Science That’s Changing Drug Development


Written by: Robin Sieg & Prof. Dr. Kathrin Adlkofer

Drug discovery is one of the most challenging and costly endeavors in the pharmaceutical industry, yet it remains fraught with inefficiencies. Despite billions in investment, nearly ninety percent of drug candidates fail in clinical trials, representing not only a staggering financial burden but also years of lost research and, most importantly, missed opportunities for patients in desperate need of effective treatments. ¹ At the heart of this inefficiency lies a fundamental issue: the reliance on outdated preclinical models, particularly animal testing, which has proven time and again to be an unreliable predictor of human responses. ² The physiological differences between species introduce variables that can lead to misleading results, causing drugs that seem promising in preclinical stages to fail once tested in humans. This systemic flaw demands a paradigm shift, one that leverages cutting-edge science to create more predictive, human-relevant testing methods.

For decades, pharmaceutical companies have relied on animal models as the gold  standard for preclinical testing, believing that they provide a necessary bridge between laboratory research and human trials. However, history has demonstrated the limitations of this approach, with many drugs that appeared safe and effective in animals proving toxic or ineffective in humans. The genetic, metabolic, and immunological differences between species mean that even the most well-designed animal studies often fail to translate into real-world success. As a result, the industry is facing growing pressure—from regulatory bodies, investors, and the broader scientific community—to adopt alternative models that better reflect human biology. This is not just a matter of scientific accuracy; it is an ethical and financial imperative.

Recent breakthroughs in biotechnology have paved the way for a transformative shift in drug discovery, one that moves beyond the constraints of animal testing toward humanized cell models that offer unprecedented precision. Among the most promising innovations are Humanized Immune System (HIS) models, which integrate human cells and tissues into experimental frameworks to replicate complex immune responses. These models allow researchers to assess how drugs interact with the human immune system in ways that were previously impossible, offering a far more accurate method for evaluating immunotherapies, vaccine candidates, and treatments for autoimmune diseases. By closely mimicking the intricate mechanisms of the human body, HIS models significantly improve the chances of identifying effective therapies earlier in the development process, reducing the likelihood of costly failures in late-stage clinical trials.

In addition to HIS models, the rise of organoids and Organs-on-Chips represents another breakthrough in pharmaceutical research. These advanced technologies enable scientists to conduct thousands of experiments using cells derived from a single human donor, creating highly scalable and physiologically relevant testing platforms. Unlike animal models, which often fail to predict long-term drug effects, organoids and Organs-on-Chips provide an unprecedented window into how human tissues interact with new compounds over extended periods. This capability allows researchers to model diseases more accurately, test drugs in environments that closely resemble the human body, and ultimately make more informed decisions before progressing to human trials. The result is a more efficient and ethical approach to drug development, one that prioritizes patient safety while accelerating the delivery of life-saving treatments.

One of the most critical aspects of drug development is ensuring that a candidate compound is not only effective but also safe. ADME/Tox testing—the assessment of a drug's absorption, distribution, metabolism, excretion, and toxicity—is a fundamental step in determining whether a drug is viable for human use. Traditional animal models frequently misrepresent how a drug will behave in humans, leading to unexpected complications in clinical trials. By contrast, humanized cell-based technologies, including microfluidic systems and bioengineered tissue models, offer far greater reliability. These systems allow scientists to study drug metabolism in a controlled environment, observing real-time interactions and detecting potential toxic effects long before human trials begin. The ability to generate high-quality predictive data at this stage of development represents a fundamental shift in pharmaceutical research, one that promises to reduce both financial risks and patient harm.


1
PREDICTABILITY FOR HUMANS
Low, since biological and genetic differences between animals and humans often lead to false results.
1
PREDICTABILITY FOR HUMANS
High because they are based on human cells and better replicate the physiological environment of humans.
2
REPRODUCIBILITY
Variable, as differences between individual animals (even within the same species) can affect results.
2
REPRODUCIBILITY
High, as standardized in vitro conditions can be maintained.
3
COST
Relatively high due to animal care, long-term studies, and ethical requirements.
3
COST
Initial costs are high, but they are more cost-effective in the long term due to higher predictability and reduced need for repeat studies.
4
ETHICAL ASPECTS
Highly controversial, as animal testing involves suffering and raises significant ethical concerns.
4
ETHICAL ASPECTS
Less problematic, as human cells are used and no animals are required.

The transition from animal models to humanized systems is no longer a theoretical discussion; it is already underway. Leading pharmaceutical companies are increasingly integrating these advanced technologies into their research pipelines, driven by compelling scientific evidence and a rapidly evolving regulatory landscape. Government agencies and regulatory bodies are beginning to recognize the limitations of animal testing and are endorsing alternative models that provide superior predictive accuracy. Meanwhile, investors are taking note of the economic potential inherent in these innovations, as humanized cell models not only improve success rates but also shorten development timelines, reducing costs and increasing returns on investment. In an industry where efficiency and accuracy determine market leadership, companies that fail to adapt risk being left behind.

As drug discovery shifts toward humanized testing methods, another critical challenge emerges: the need for reliable and precise transport solutions for fragile cell-based models. The effectiveness of these models depends on their ability to maintain their integrity and function throughout the research and development process, which requires carefully controlled transport conditions. This is where Cellbox Solutions is playing a pivotal role. By developing advanced transport technologies specifically designed for humanized cell models, Cellbox ensures that researchers have access to high-quality, fully viable test systems wherever they are needed. The Cellbox™ Shipper, designed for long-distance transport, provides precise temperature and CO₂ regulation to preserve the stability of cell cultures. For shorter distances, the Cellbox™ Go offers a compact, high-performance solution, ensuring that research facilities and clinical trial sites receive cell models in optimal condition. These innovations are not just logistical solutions—they are essential enablers of modern drug discovery.

The shift toward humanized drug discovery represents one of the most significant advancements in pharmaceutical research in decades. Companies that embrace these innovations will lead the next generation of medicine, pioneering treatments that are not only safer and more effective but also developed with greater efficiency and ethical responsibility. By replacing outdated animal models with human-relevant alternatives, pharmaceutical firms can dramatically improve their chances of clinical success, reduce costs, and bring transformative treatments to market faster than ever before. This is not just about keeping up with the future—it is about actively shaping it.

At Cellbox Solutions, we are committed to supporting this transformation. We are actively seeking partnerships with pharmaceutical companies, biotech firms, and research institutions to integrate our transport solutions into real-world drug discovery applications.

The pharmaceutical industry is evolving, and those who act now will be the ones to set the standards for the next generation of medicine. The future of drug discovery is here. The only question that remains is: will you be leading it?


Contact us today to explore collaboration opportunities and be part of the revolution that is redefining pharmaceutical research.



¹ Minikel EV, Painter JL, Dong CC, Nelson MR. Refining the impact of genetic evidence on clinical success. Nature. 2024 May;629(8012):624-629. doi: 10.1038/s41586-024-07316-0. Epub 2024 Apr 17. PMID: 38632401; PMCID: PMC11096124.

² Van Norman GA. Limitations of Animal Studies for Predicting Toxicity in Clinical Trials: Is it Time to Rethink Our Current Approach? JACC Basic Transl Sci. 2019 Nov 25;4(7):845-854. doi: 10.1016/j.jacbts.2019.10.008. PMID: 31998852; PMCID: PMC6978558.